I used to be notoriously bad at baking cookies. Any cookies I baked would always come out flat. I am not sure whether or not it was because of the obsessive butter beating or the excessive bowl scraping habit I have. When the recipe says, “Beat butter and sugars until light and fluffy”, I had to make sure all of the butter and sugar’s atoms are evenly distributed in the batter. I would turn on the mixer, beat butter and sugar, turn it off to scrape the bowl… over and over… until the batter looks “perfect”.
Not until I stumbled upon Jacque Torres’ chocolate chips cookies recipe that I, never again, made flat cookies. They were fool proof or flat proof, I should say. My chocolate chip cookies were always perfectly round — not too flat, not too thick and perfectly chewy. I have also made Smitten Kitchen’s thick, chewy oatmeal raisin cookies. They, too, came out perfect: not flat and chewy. Today was a different story.
I wanted something sweet. And, I wanted to bake because it was one of those cooler days in Seattle. At first, I wanted oatmeal raisin cookies, then I thought that I have made that before and I wanted something slightly different. So, I thought I would make oatmeal cookies, but with sour cherries and white chocolate. I was about to use the thick and chewy oatmeal raisin recipe I made before but with sour cherries and white chocolate chunks instead. But, I came across this recipe; and I thought, for once, let’s just bake! I’m not going to change anything…just make it the way the recipe is written.
I followed the recipe. I didn’t change a thing. I beat the butter and sugars until light and fluffy like it said, added everything accordingly, and baked them at the right temperature. But! They came out flat! I admit that I was disappointed. I thought I was cured from making flat cookies. I was wrong.
However, once I took a bite out of one of these cookies, I couldn’t care less what they look like. The taste is perfectly balanced. They are sweet and salty with fleur de sel on top. It’s also possible that I am imagining this, but the white chocolate gives out a hint of caramel — that makes you go, “Mmmm”. These cookies really make my day. They are so addictive that you can’t just have one. And, they are perfect just the way they are.
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.